Seeking the Hiding God: A Personal Theological Essay

Jewish Theological Seminary professor Eisen (Rethinking Modern Judaism) delivers a stimulating exploration of his belief in a God. Drawing on a realization that shaped his faith during college (“God is here with us in the world, though not necessarily to be found by you or me or anyone else”), Eisen considers the purpose of prayer, the personal connection to the divine, and the challenge of resolving one’s faith with such horrors as the Holocaust. On the latter topic, he cites a biblical passage stating that God’s “countenance” can be “hidden at one point and unmistakably visible at another.” While readers seeking definitive answers might be frustrated with Eisen’s willingness to embrace uncertainty, the curious will find plenty to appreciate in the mix of historical examples, sharp rabbinical insight, and reassurances that theological doubt can coexist with a meaningful Jewish life if one focuses on the here and now. “The good that we are called to do in this life is in our reach,” Eisen writes, “even though answers to the ultimate mysteries are not in our hands.” It’s a thought-provoking addition to the bookshelf on modern Jewish theology. (Sept.)