Daughter of the Shining Isles
Elizabeth Cunningham. Barrytown Limited, $24.95 (362pp) ISBN 978-1-58177-060-5
According to the publicity material accompanying her new book, novelist Cunningham (The Return of the Goddess) is descended from nine generations of Episcopal priests. She resisted the temptation to become a Christian priest herself, but proudly calls herself a priestess, and has written reams of feminist, neo-pagan fiction. In this novel, the first in a projected trilogy, Cunningham introduces us to Mary Magdalen, Celtic-style. Here, Mary, called Maeve, is born in the Land of Women in 4 B.C.E. As a young woman, she moves to Mona to study at a druidic university. There she meets Esus--aka Jesus--who is also studying there during his so-called lost years. In Maeve, Cunningham has blended the perky insouciance of Sabrina the teenage witch with the penetrating common sense of Jane Austen's Elizabeth Bennett. She speaks in a refreshingly modern voice--""Yes, I know. Girl hero is awkward, like woman doctor.... But I balk at the word heroine. A personal quirk."" But awkward locutions creep into this historical fantasy (""It was the blood, my woman's blood!""), and much of the novel reads like a poor imitation of Ursula Le Guin. At times, Cunningham tries too hard to prove her bona fides; her references to the Talmud, for example, hardly blend in seamlessly. (""You'll find this very discussion in a volume called Taharoth, in the tractate Niddah, chapter 9, Mishnah 5."") The endearing protagonist almost makes plowing through the tendentious, turgid prose worthwhile. Almost, but not quite. (June)
Details
Reviewed on: 05/29/2000
Genre: Fiction