Eros of Parenthood
Noelle Oxenhandler. Golden Books, $25.95 (304pp) ISBN 978-0-312-26976-0
In an attempt to reclaim the primal intimacy of the parent-child bond from dogmatists who see close physical affection as suspect or indecent, Oxenhandler (A Grief Out of Season) argues that parental love is inherently erotic. Despite her flamboyant terminology, what Oxenhandler means is that the parent-child bond can have the same physical and emotional intensity as a bond between lovers. There is, she points out, some scientific basis for this magnetism. The chemical oxytocin ""controls a woman's pleasure during orgasm, childbirth, cuddling and nursing."" Meanwhile, a child's ""irresistibleness"" in infancy is also a mechanism for survival. But Oxenhandler soon leaves science behind in favor of addressing the different ""erotic"" feelings a parent may experience. Throughout, she stresses the importance of ""attunement,"" a process by which parents modify their physical affection as their children grow older--after all, the same caresses one showers on a baby are hardly appropriate for an adolescent. While the subtitle suggests an evenhanded treatment of the ""light"" and ""dark"" aspects of the parent-child relationship, Oxenhandler is much more skillful at presenting its sunnier side. She admits she has little experience in dealing with victims of child abuse, incest or pedophilia, and her attitude toward these issues may strike some readers as dismissive and uninformed. (In one chapter she suggests that adults use ""playfulness"" as an alternative to slipping into forbidden territory, though that seems an unlikely remedy to true pedophilic impulses.) Despite the flaws in her argument, many parents will find some comfort in this beautifully written book, which reassures them about the pleasure they may find in their child's natural curiosity and unconscious sexuality. (Feb.)
Details
Reviewed on: 03/01/2001
Genre: Nonfiction