The Alternatives

A 39-year-old geology professor disappears from her Galway campus, prompting her three sisters to reunite and track her down, in the intelligent if uneven latest from Hughes (The Wild Laughter). When Olwen Flattery was 18, her parents died in an accidental fall from a cliff, and she became legal guardian of her three younger sisters: Maeve, a celebrity chef in London whose recipes Hughes presents as simultaneously silly and delectable (a “fancy fish taco” comprises “red mullet with anchovy-rosemary sauce on a cabbage leaf”); Nell, an adjunct philosophy professor at a Connecticut college; and Rhona, a hard-headed Dublin political scientist. At times, Hughes reaches for dark comedy, as when she describes how both parents ended up at the bottom of the cliff (“the heavier one reached out to grasp her—reached too far; grasped too well”). Elsewhere, she strikes an earnest note as the women reunite in Ireland and reckon with Olwen’s history of alcoholism. The inconsistent tone can be jarring, but Hughes shines when weaving the dense intellectual material of the three academic sisters’ work into their dialogue (“Just don’t start on about the mind-body separateness of a pint of Guinness,” Maeve jokes to Nell). This one perplexes and stimulates in equal measure. Agent: Bill Clegg, Clegg Agency. (Apr.)